Showing posts with label appraisal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label appraisal. Show all posts

Thursday, July 25, 2013

Look Out for Morty!

I recently took part in a discussion where the topic was the ability of a lender to call a loan; in that specific instance, a businessman's line of credit. This discussion covered the reappraisal of mortgaged real estate. In a changing market, a lender may want to gauge the change in the degree of risk (lenders may require additional collateral or may reduce the line of credit if the value of the collateral becomes less than the loan amount), and also touched upon "due on sale" clauses.

A typical mortgage deed might contain something like the following (which is the actual text from an actual mortgage):

"18. Transfer of the Property or a Beneficial Interest in Borrower. As used in this Section 18, "Interest in the Property" means any legal or beneficial interest in the Property, including, but not limited to, those beneficial interests transferred in a bond for deed, contract for deed, installment sales contract or escrow agreement, the intent of which is the transfer of title by Borrower at a future date to a purchaser.

If all or any part of the Property or any Interest in the Property is sold or transferred (or if Borrower is not a natural person and a beneficial interest in Borrower is sold or transferred) without Lender's prior written consent, Lender may require immediate payment in full of all sums secured by this Security Instrument. However, this option shall not be exercised by Lender if such exercise is prohibited by Applicable Law.

If Lender exercises this option, Lender shall give Borrower notice of acceleration. The notice shall provide a period of not less than 30 days from the date the notice is given in accordance with Section 15 within which Borrower must pay all sums secured by this Security Instrument. If Borrower fails to pay these sums prior to the expiration of this period, Lender may invoke any remedies permitted by this Security Instrument without further notice or demand on Borrower."

While the likelihood of foreclosure on a residential property due to the above clause is currently not very high because there are so many foreclosures clogging the market, an understanding of what is actually owned and mortgaged is frequently missing in the mind of a typical homeowner.

The popular view of a piece of residential real estate is a plot of dirt with a house on it. While it is true that these items are useful, the actual real estate is something different. Some definitions are in order.

estate : A right or interest in property. Defines an owner’s degree, quantity, nature, and extent of interest in real property. There are many different types of estates, including freehold (fee simple, determinable fee, and life estate) and leasehold. To be an estate in land, an interest must allow possession (either now or in the future) and be differentiated primarily by its duration.

freehold estate : An estate or possessory interest in land that lasts for an indeterminable length of time, such as for a lifetime or forever. Examples include fee simple (also called an indefeasible fee), defeasible fee, and life estates. The first two continue for an indefinite period and are inheritable by the heirs of the owner. The life estate terminates upon the death of the person on whose life it is based.

fee simple estate : Absolute ownership unencumbered by any other interest or estate, subject only to the limitations imposed by the governmental powers of taxation, eminent domain, police power, and escheat.

leased fee interest : A freehold (ownership interest) where the possessory interest has been granted to another party by creation of a contractual landlord-tenant relationship (i.e., a lease).

leasehold interest : The tenant’s possessory interest created by a lease.

Source: Appraisal Institute, The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, 5th ed. (Chicago: Appraisal Institute, 2010).

Typically, when the buyer and seller of a residential property reach a meeting of the minds, the transaction that takes place is a transfer of a fee simple interest in the land and improvements. Theoretically (within the limits imposed by government), the owner of the fee simple interest may sell off all the materials that make up the improvements, and/or all the dirt, rocks, water, oil, or other minerals within the bounds of the property to the center of the Earth and still have the fee simple rights to the empty space left. He would have sold all the "stuff" that was on his real estate, but not the actual real estate itself.

This is one of the hardest concepts to pound into the heads of real estate appraisers, their lender clients, and the borrowers against the real estate. What is being appraised for a mortgage loan is not the dirt and sticks (although they play a part in determining what is available for quiet enjoyment of the real estate) but the market value of the bundle of rights that belong to the mortgagor. In fact, the FNMA/FHLMC forms used to report the appraisal clearly identify the Property Rights Appraised at the very top of the first page. In most cases, the lender is loaning money on the fee simple interest.

This creates some interesting potential problems for the mortgagor. Note that the lender reserves the right to call the loan if any interest in the property is sold without the lender's prior written consent. Let's look at some scenarios.

Pitfall #1. Big Bean Gas Company is aggregating parcels for a drilling unit, and strikes a deal with a group of owners in a subdivision for rights to the shale gas under their lots. Selling the rights to any possible underlying gas is a reduction of the fee simple interest in the property; under clause #18 in the mortgage above, it could trigger an acceleration of the loan payback, including a demand for immediate payment in full.

Pitfall #2. Joe Homeowner wants to move but can't sell his home due to the poor real estate market. He can, however, rent it out. He finds a perfect tenant, and signs a one year lease. The tenant now has a leasehold interest; the fee simple interest has been diminished (even if only for 12 months), and if the lease was entered into without the prior written consent of the mortgagee, acceleration is possible.

It is vital to remember that when a person mortgages real estate, he is signing a deed which gives most of his rights in the estate to the mortgagee in the event that a default situation occurs. It is a sale with a right of redemption. The mortgagor retains the rights to possession and quiet enjoyment of the estate, but those rights are only on loan from the new owner, the mortgagee, until the terms of the mortgage are complete. The rest of the rights to the estate may belong to the lender, and if the mortgagor attempts to take those rights back without the mortgagee's approval, it could be a trespass which could forfeit the entire estate to the mortgagee in foreclosure. When you borrow money, and grant a mortgage deed to the lender, be sure to carefully read the terms of that deed.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

A Look at Disposition Value & Liquidation Value


A common instruction in an engagement letter in these times might include wording such as:



"Please provide both the current market value and the disposition value based on a 9 month market period for the fee simple interest."



As compliance reviewers, my colleague, Richard Rexroad, SRA, and I have noted on numerous occasions what appears to be total confusion among the ranks of appraisers as to what exactly is meant by "disposition value". Certainly, the definition of disposition value is easily found for, and cited in, their reports, but the summary statements that include their opinions of disposition value may be of marginal use -- or worse, no use at all -- to the client.



To try to ascertain the resources available to appraisers for reference on the subject, a search was made of all media in the Appraisal Institute's Lum Library using the keywords "disposition value". The search returned one resource, Appraisal Institute Special Task Force on Value Definitions, June 1992 by Schultz, Featherston, Gibbons, LeGrand, and Parson. That work proposed definitions of disposition value and liquidation value, both of which appear to have subsequently been defined following their proposal. No further modern references could be located in the Lum Library.



Perhaps the best starting point for the discussion would lie in examining the Assignment Type and Intended Use of the report. After the highjacking of the URAR form by Fannie and Freddie in 2005, and the hardcoding of the Intended Use ("The intended use of this appraisal report is for the lender/client to evaluate the property that is the subject of this appraisal for a mortgage finance transaction."), most residential appraisers gave no further thought to that matter. For the most part, the assignments were for either purchases or refinances; no other discussion of the intended use was needed.



With the increase in inventory of REO properties and the periodic need to analyze the value of the collateral with a view toward asset disposition, lenders holding residential properties in their portfolios have been ordering large numbers of appraisals for the purpose of collateral analysis rather than mortgage finance. The AI Reports forms (which would be a much better choice for the task) have been ignored by the lending community. Appraisals for collateral analysis have been ordered, almost without exception, on the FNMA 2005 series of forms, most likely because that is what the lenders are most familiar with.



Because the FNMA/FHLMC forms are intended to be used for mortgage finance rather than disposition of the asset, the change in Intended Use is in direct conflict with the hard-coded statement in the report, and very few residential appraisers (even among those holding various designations from professional associations) have seen fit to add language in the addenda to the report which will supercede the hard-coded verbiage.



[Note: The forms do state that "Modifications, additions, or deletions to the intended use, intended user, definition of market value, or assumptions and limiting conditions are not permitted.", and then two exceptions are cited. However, that restriction applies ONLY to the use of the form for a FNMA/FHLMC mortgage transaction. The GSEs cannot prohibit the use of the form for other purposes; the key to their USPAP-compliant use in such situations is to adequately provide overriding verbiage in an addendum regarding the intended use, intended user, definition of value (and the source of the definition), assumptions, conditions, limitations, and certifications. ]



This discussion does not purport to address all forms of deviation from the hardcoded verbiage in the FNMA/FHLMC forms, but appraisers using those forms for other than a mortgage finance transaction need to keep the above factors under consideration.



When the assignment stipulates that the purpose is in the nature of collateral analysis for disposition of the asset, the client will frequently request either a disposition or liquidation value opinion along with the current market value opinion. In doing so, the client is first looking for the present value of the asset as though it had been offered on the open market at competitive terms with all other properties comparable to it. The typical exposure time for the subject must be analyzed and reported for the current market value. In that analysis, the appraiser will also be analyzing the market supply and pricing trends of competitive homes; all these factors are supposed to be summarized on page 1 of the FNMA report form.



Development of current market value is a straightforward process for most residential appraisers. Their major concern with the neighborhood market trend information is to develop adequate adjustments for the comparable sales, based on their distance in time from the effective date of the report. When the assignment adds the requirement to develop an opinion of disposition or liquidation value, however, there will be an application of the trends to the stated marketing period along with additional consideration of the motivation of the seller.



An examination of the definitions of these values is in order:




















































Market ValueDisposition ValueLiquidation Value
12 CRF 323.2(g)Dict. of RE Appraisal (4th Ed)Dict. of RE Appraisal (4th Ed)
Consummation of a sale as of a specified date.Consummation of a sale will occur within a limited future marketing period specified by the client.Consummation of a sale will occur within a severely limited future marketing period specified by the client.
Competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale.The actual market conditions currently prevailing are those to which the appraised property interest is subject.The actual market conditions currently prevailing are those to which the appraised property interest is subject.
The buyer and seller each acting prudently and knowledgeably.The buyer and seller each acting prudently and knowledgeably.The buyer acting prudently and knowledgeably.
Assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus, buyer and seller are typically motivated.The seller is under compulsion to sell, the buyer is typically motivated.The seller is under extreme compulsion to sell, the buyer is typically motivated.
Both parties are well informed or well advised, and acting in what they consider their own best interests.Both parties are acting in what they consider their best interests.The buyer is acting in what he or she considers his or her best interest.
A reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market.An adequate marketing effort will be made in the limited time allowed for the completion of a sale.A limited marketing effort and time will be allowed for the completion of a sale.
Payment is made in terms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto.Payment will be made in cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto.Payment will be made in cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto.
The price represents the normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale. The price represents the normal consideration for the property sold, unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale.The price represents the normal consideration for the property sold, unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale.



Standards Rule 1-2 requires that the appraiser identify the Intended Use of the appraisal. It seems to be a difficult thing for appraisers to ask clients, "What do you intend to do with my opinion?", yet that is critical to understanding how the problem must be approached. The appraiser cannot render a useful opinion of value without understanding the motivation of the participants in the market. We seem to clearly understand that a market value opinion will be used to make a decision regarding underwriting a mortgage loan. Sadly, there seems to be a failure to understand why a client would request a disposition or liquidation value; the client assumes we know, and we assume they understand what we are about to deliver.



Let us step into the shoes of the lender with an asset which needs to be sold. The lender first wishes to know what his collateral is worth today -- the current market value. That value assumes that the subject has been on the market for its reasonable exposure period. In studying that exposure period, the appraiser will note the change in the market from the beginning of the exposure period to the effective date of the appraisal; that market change information will be critical in making adjustments to the comparable sales.



Unfortunately for the client, he is holding the subject in his inventory today, without a sales contract. He realizes that in order to get a contract, he will have to market the property. He has certain parameters for market time. Let us assume that the market is slow and the reasonable exposure period for the subject might be 6 months. The client knows that it will take time to sell the subject; acting prudently (see the definition of disposition value) he is willing to extend the market time to a maximum of 9 months, and orders a disposition value based on a 9 month market period. What is he telling us he wants? Have we really learned the definition of the value type?



Perhaps the client tells us his intent is to know what the property will be worth 9 months from now by asking for a disposition value based on a 9 month market period. That is a prospective value opinion which the appraiser will need to develop by adjusting the current market value for any anticipated change in the market over the 9 month period, as well as his knowledge, perhaps gleaned from anecdotal evidence in talking with sales brokers, of typical discounts in the subject market when properties sell under compulsion. Similarly to forecasting in a relocation appraisal, the 9-month disposition value thus arrived at gives the client a far end of a range (current market value is the near end) within which he can hope to sell the property during that time period. If an offer comes in within that range, the client now has a tool he can use to judge the acceptability of the offer. As the 1992 Task Force noted, in a declining market, the disposition value opinion would probably be lower than current market value, but in a rising market, it possibly could be higher.



Development of a liquidation value opinion would follow the same general pattern, with a subtle difference -- the factor of extreme compulsion to sell, coupled with the facts that the marketing effort would be limited and the seller might not be acting prudently. In such a situation, the place to turn for the anecdotal market conditions would be the auctioneer who specializes in absolute auctions with no reserve. Such an opinion would need to be formed with the mindset that the specified market period for the subject would anticipate an absolute auction at its termination, with a view toward informing the client that any offer he received within that time period which fell into the range would likely be one to which serious consideration should be given.



Nevertheless, regardless the trend of pricing in the marketplace, the anecdotal evidence will be crucial to the development of either type of value. There simply is not enough reliable statistical information readily available to the average residential appraiser for this purpose. The subjective nature of anecdotal data should not be viewed as lacking validity; the decisions behind the motivation and actions of the typical seller in disposition or liquidation scenarios are similarly subjective and valid. The appraiser is not being misleading as long as full disclosure of the kind of data source is made.



What is not valid, and is indeed unethical, is to postulate an opinion of value without understanding the intended use of the appraisal, or acknowledging the conditions explicit in the definition of that value.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Dumping Workfiles

Visitors to my basement at one time were treated to the sight of dozens of file storage boxes stacked there. The majority of those appraisal workfiles dated from my tenure as a staff appraiser from 2003 - 2004. USPAP requires that a copy of the appraisal and the workfile be retained for 5 years from the effective date of the valuation. After that the files can be discarded, but the rules governing client confidentiality have to be followed. As a result, when the files reach their fifth birthday, I use them to heat the house.

While going through the boxes (yes, I do glance at the reports to make sure I do not inadvertently destroy something which should be retained) I found the following peer review done by a third appraiser regarding my appraisal of a home and the value opinion provided by another appraiser retained by a litigious borrower:

"November 4, 2004

I have been asked to review two appraisal reports that were completed on this property. The first report was completed by James Hrubik based on an interior viewing of the home on February 12, 2004 and the indicated opinion of value was stated as $33,000. A second report was completed for a different client by Appraiser X based on an interior viewing of the home on August 18, 2004 and the indicated opinion of value is stated as $70,000. For this review I viewed the exterior of the subject property and all comparable sales used and have attached photos of these properties and a location map to this review. Please note that approximately six months have transpired between the effective dates of these reports and I am therefore unable to confirm if the condition of the home had changed in this period of time.

For this review, I surveyed the Akron Area MLS and public record information. The MLS describes this neighborhood as Southwest Akron and is Area SUM34. Per the MLS there had been a total of 93 sales of single family homes of all property ages and styles in the twelve months preceding the effective date of Mr. Hrubik’s report. The price range was $3,000 to $134,900 with nearly 2/3 of all sales ranging between $3,000 to $30,000, and many were described as being ‘Bank Owned’. The median price was $21,500 and virtually every sale between $71,900 to $134,900 was described as being a ‘New’ home.

The report completed by Mr. Hrubik provides a neighborhood description that states this is an urban neighborhood with property price ranges between $10,000 and $125,000 with a predominant price of $40,000. The age range is described as being from New to 100+ years with a predominant age of 80 years, which is reasonable and consistent with MLS data. Mr. Hrubik selected three sales for his analysis that were offered in the MLS and I was able to verify the sale price and property features as reported based on the MLS descriptions and public record information as follows:

Comparable #1: 643 W. Thornton sold in 9-2003 at $30,000 after being listed at $32,000 for 54 days. The property descriptions are consistent though Mr. Hrubik fails to report that this home was reported to have a finished basement rec room with wet bar and a negative adjustment could have been included. There was no prior sale or listing of this home in the previous 36 months.

Comparable #2: 987 Laurel Avenue sold in 10-2003 at $29,500 after being listed at $32,900 for 119 days. The property descriptions are consistent with the data sources noted. Though there was no prior sale of this home in the 36 months prior to the date of value, the home had been offered for sale in the MLS on two previous occasions, once at $49,900 for 184 days until the listing expired on 2-14-2002 and again at $39,900 for 92 days until the listing expired on 7-31-2002.

Comparable #3: 994 Celina Avenue sold in 10-2003 at $33,530 after being listed at $34,900 for 122 days. The property descriptions are consistent with the data sources noted. There was no prior sale or listing of this home in the 36 months prior to the date of value.

All three sales are in close proximity, similar in age and living area, and were within six months of the effective date of value and are therefore considered relevant and reasonable. Each was listed for sale with a professional Realtor and had adequate market exposure in the MLS.

As noted, I was also provided an appraisal report completed by Appraiser X for a different client and have found a number of significant deficiencies with the report. The neighborhood is described as being ‘Suburban’ rather than ‘Urban’. The neighborhood price range is stated as $50,000 to $90,000+ with a predominant price of $60-75,000 which clearly contradicts MLS data for this neighborhood. In addition the age range is 60 to 100 years which does not include a significant number of homes in this market that are much less than 60 years old. Appraiser X fails to provide the FEMA flood zone information which leads me to question if she had adequate data sources for this community. The land value estimate of $15,000 is not reasonable for a site of 32’ x 132’ in this urban setting as this is more than 50% of the total sale price of nearly 2/3 of the reported sales in the MLS as noted above. Finally, Appraiser X provided three sales in the market analysis that were non-MLS transactions. The data source stated (Auditor’s Office/Exterior Inspection) does not provide information regarding any terms of sale, property condition, or if the transaction was at market and arm’s length. Other concerns regarding these sales are as follows:

Comparable #1: 817 Raymond is reported to have sold in 4-2004 at $72,000 per public record information. Appraiser X states that there was no prior sale of this home in the preceding 36 months. However, this home was offered in the MLS at $20,000 in 1-2004 and transferred to SMB & A LLC in 1-2004 at $14,000. The home then was sold in 4-2004 at $72,000 with terms and conditions of the transaction not known nor is there verification that the home had been restored for this purchase. Appraiser X’s failure to disclose the previous recent sale is a violation of USPAP and leads me to question if this was actually a ‘flip’ transaction.

Comparable #2: 1006 Nathan is reported to have sold in 11-2003 at $67,000 per public record and seller. Appraiser X fails to disclose that the [n.b. - I deleted this buyer-seller relationship disclosure for retention of confidentiality] and is likely biased toward the transaction. Failure to disclose this relevant information regarding the seller is considered misleading as a typical reader would assume this was a verified and unbiased transaction. There was no prior sale or listing of this home in the 36 months prior to the effective date of value.

Comparable #3: 640 W. Thornton is reported to have sold in 2-2004 at $75,000 per public record, The data source can not be used to verify the terms and conditions of this transaction nor the condition of the home at the time of its sale. However, upon my exterior viewing on November 3, 2004 this home appears to have been vacated and at least one window is broken which again leads me to question the reliability of this sale. No other sale or listing in the preceding 36 months was found in data sources for this property.

It is highly unusual for a qualified appraiser to not utilize the MLS as a primary data source for this established urban neighborhood in the city of Akron, which leads me to question if Appraiser X had adequate experience or resources to have accepted this appraisal request.

For the purposes of this review, I also surveyed the MLS for active listings in the subject’s neighborhood to help establish a reasonable upper limit of value for homes of similar vintage.

Currently, a property at 388 Raasch Avenue is offered for sale at $45,000. This home is described in the MLS as being completely renovated including newer drywall, carpet, furnace, A/C, windows, roof, kitchen with oak cabinets, newer bathroom. The home is reported to have been built in 1925 and offers 1128 sq ft living area, which would be competitive with the subject. As noted, this home has yet to sell and has been on the market for over 200 days. It is my opinion that this active listing provides some helpful insight into this neighborhood for homes that are renovated to this degree.

For these reasons I am of the opinion that the value as reported by Appraiser X is without merit or support. The neighborhood description does not accurately reflect the reality of the predominant sales activity in this market area. The use of questionable or unreliable sales data without utilizing the MLS in this market, or seeking assistance from someone with access to the MLS, leads the reader of the report to unreasonable conclusions and for this reason the report is misleading."


I remember that incident well, as I was required to sit beside my client's attorney as we faced the borrower and his counsel. That is how I managed to get a copy of the review. Also, because the report was involved in litigation, it and all pertinent files need to be retained an additional five years beyond the settlement of the dispute.

The rest of the story? The borrower (who wanted to borrow about $60,000) claimed my client would have made the loan had the borrower been a member of a protected group. Appraiser X, whose office was 60 miles away, was brought in to make the case that I had significantly undervalued the home and that my client had utilized it in an attempt to prevent the loan. It is of interest that I was not named in the suit; there was nothing in my report which could have been interpreted as bias. I just had not come up with the correct number, and my client trusted my judgment.

No mention was made anywhere in the proceedings that the tax appraised value of the home was only $30,750. My client settled out of court by agreeing to hire a fourth appraiser who managed to appraise the subject property for about $45,000, thereby allowing the client to loan the borrower the tax appraisal amount and still stay within Federal guidelines.

To my knowledge the second appraisal was never submitted to the Ohio Division of Real Estate for review; protection of Appraiser X was possibly a part of the settlement. Now you may have a bit more insight into why the banking industry was in need of a stimulus in 2008.

Thursday, November 26, 2009

Time Flies

It has been several very busy months since the last post. I have been busy gathering and verifying tax card information for the Geauga County Auditor in order to provide an updated database for the 2011 reappraisal in that county. In doing so, I have been logging experience hours in non-residential appraisal work, to be applied toward my application to sit for the General Appraiser certification exam.

Meanwhile, while not intending to do so, I have failed to provide a follow-up on the query that was the subject of the last post. I received the following reply (in part) to the information I sent to the troubled borrower:
Jim,

Thank you for the information and your thoughts. I will certainly take your advise
[sic]. I noticed that remodeling averages are from 65%-77% depending on the project which certainly shows the appraisal was estimated much lower. I understand what the auditor's records show but they came in here and documented 4 bdrm and 3 full baths. Are we paying for an accurate appraisal? Two more questions 1) how is land value figured? And replacement cost per sq ft? Our insurance company has it much much higher. I'm just trying to wrap my mind around this as to why it came in so low. We had this same thing happen before were [sic] the first appraisal came in much lower 50-60000. We spoke with Chase and explained everything and they issued another appraisal. The appraiser who came out has intimate knowledge of our area in fact he explained the his mother is a Realtor in this area and he knows the value. It came in at $399,000.


I never did email the man back, but my notes on my thoughts have been cluttering my desk for the past 5 months, so here goes.

First off, the last few sentences of his email are very troubling to me. If, during the original loan's appraisal process, the value came in $50-60K less than what was "needed", and the bank sent out a second appraiser who "knows the value", I, as a very suspicious, untrusting, and experienced reviewer tend to immediately class the second appraiser as one who could also "hit the value", whatever it took. Sorry, I have not just one noid, but a paranoid where these matters fall.

Is the borrower "paying for an accurate appraisal"? I suppose that is a very nuanced question. By law, the client is the bank. The borrower pays for the appraisal, but the bank is the intended user. Certainly the bank should be interested in a well reasoned and factually supported opinion of value, but the words "accurate" and "opinion" do not belong in the same sentence without some other explanatory verbiage. The facts should be accurate, and the opinion should be unbiased.

Certifications 1, 4, 7, 9, 11, and 12 of the FMNA Form 1004 (3/2005) address the accuracy and adequacy of the data used in the analysis. Adjustments may be difficult in a declining market with a scarcity of sales, and the appraiser must use his best judgment. Much more attention is also being paid now by lenders to geographic competency (Certification 11) -- where does the appraiser live and normally work, and is he truly familiar with the market? n.b. -- it should be recognized that an appraiser can become extremely competent in a market at some distance from his normal base, but the onus is on the appraiser to prove such competency in both his choice of data and the resulting reasoning.

As to the value of the land, there are three normally accepted methods for determining land value (the value of the land as vacant and unimproved). The first is market sales comparison. Examination of recent sales of vacant buildable parcels should provide the appraiser with information to form an opinion of value for the subject parcel. The subject parcel had 2.65 acres; the borrower cited a 1 acre lot selling for $78,000. That would be a very poor comparable in a built-up area like the City of Solon; more comparable sales would be vacant residential lots between 2.5 and 3 acres in size, and such sales would be extremely rare. The $5750 adjustment for site size would be the appraiser's opinion of the contributory value of the site size difference; the important thing there is support for the site value which the appraiser is supposed to detail on page 3 of the Form 1004. That support is required by FNMA, regardless whether the Cost Approach is completed. (We'll discuss that a little further on.)

The other two commonly used methods for determining site value are extraction and allocation. Allocation is fairly simple and is built into most models for AVMs and CAMA. In its simplest form, when the cost to build the house, new, is calculated, a percentage figure is multiplied by the cost to give a land value. In its most reliable form, the percentage is derived from market studies of builder costs, and is adjusted internally for positive and negative land features. In practice, however, it is often a "pluck from air" (PFA) figure and, within assessment records, frequently produces hilarious results. (Sorry, but I have in mind a lot in the City of Akron which had an old house on it. The year the house was demolished, the lot was valued by the Auditor at $8,000. The next year, with a new house -- built with government grant money and not at all a market-driven project -- on the lot, the tax appraisal land value had jumped to $20,000. The mean and median price of housing in the neighborhood was unchanged. Such is the magic of carelessly applied allocation.)

Within built-up areas with few vacant land sales, extraction is the third commonly used method for determining site value. To properly do a land value extraction, sales comparisons must be run on a number of recent sales of homes where significant details of their quality and condition are known to the appraiser. The appraiser must do a Cost Approach appraisal of each of the comparable homes (comparable in this context being more applicable to the characteristics of the land than the houses), with great care taken to account for all forms of depreciation that might have affected those homes. The resultant depreciated cost of the improvements is then subtracted from the raw sales price to indicate the contributory value of the land under the home. Unfortunately, while many appraisers cite extraction as their method for determining site value, it is my experience from looking at their reports that a good many of them either have no idea what they are about, or they are incredibly lazy.

In general, FNMA does not require the Cost Approach to be completed on the Form 1004 unless it is the appraiser's opinion that it is needed to provide support for the reasoning behind the value opinion. Appraisers generally use cost tables to determine the cost to construct the home using current methods and materials, and then apply estimates of depreciation (physical, functional, and external) to arrive at a depreciated cost of the improvements. This is then added to the site value figure to indicate a market value for the home. In theory, it works if an honest site value is used and if all three forms of depreciation are properly accounted for. Lenders want to see the Cost Approach used because they feel it is a shortcut to providing a figure for which they can require the borrower to supply an insurance policy. Most appraisers are now including a disclaimer that the costs "are not to be considered indicative of insurance replacement costs", this despite the fact that the form requires them to check that the costs are either for reproduction or replacement.

An insurance appraisal is generally not a market value appraisal. Insurance policies are written to allow property owners to recover the utility of their asset if it is fully or partially destroyed. Replacement cost per square foot, for insurance purposes, must include the costs involved in removing any debris from a damaged home, and then reconstructing it to its former usefullness. This means that no depreciation can be entered into the process, since the home, when the owner again takes up residence in it, will be restored to "new" condition. The replacement cost may be, and usually is, far more than the market value of the home. If the home is purchased for $100,000, but is of such age and design and condition that to rebuild it to modern standards would cost $200,000, the borrower may only be required by the lender to insure it for the purchase price. If it burns to the ground and must be rebuilt, the insurance company will only pay the policy amount. The borrower will have to come up with the rest. If he cannot qualify for the additional loan amount, or does not have the cash, he may have to default on the original loan. Consequently, homeowners should have their houses independently appraised for insurance purposes, and under no conditions should they rely on a market value appraisal for insurance value uses.

There is one final thing cloesly related to the above which needs to be mentioned and which will make me persona non grata in some circles. The gentleman who originally wrote to me acknowledged in his rejoinder that "I noticed that remodeling averages are from 65%-77% depending on the project". A dirty little secret is that this also applies to new construction, albeit to a lesser degree. Just like a new car, which loses value the instant it is driven off the dealer's lot, in a stable market, a new house depreciates, possibly 5% - 15% depending on where it is located, the instant the buyer signs the contract with the builder. The practice of selling new homes with 100% financing is still occurring, but it is not politically expedient to suggest to FNMA that new home buyers should be required to put down 20-25% of the purchase price in cash. Especially not with the government trying to stimulate the economy by offering tax incentives in a market that is in significant oversupply.

Hi-yo, Silver! Away!

Friday, June 12, 2009

Comparing Oranges to Oranges

I get some interesting questions from time to time. While I cannot directly address the concerns some people have about home value (the instant I utter my opinion of value, even orally and/or "off the cuff", I have done a certified appraisal and am required to submit to the person receiving the opinion (even though a client relationship may not exist) a signed certification. So, I have to be careful. Still, as I said, some of these things are interesting and bear a little research.

Here is a sample, dated today:


Jim,

We just had an appraisal completed, which feel $105,000 short of the appraisal completed 11/07 KeyBank. We understand the market trend in today's economy. However we live in an area that is still maintaining a good home value- Orange Village. The appraiser used comps that are 3 bdrm 2 to 1 full baths 2 car garage and the homes are 48, 53 & 35 years old which our is 30. Also our home sits on 2.65 acres heavily wood lot and the comps are 1.65, 1.48 & .35 not on wood lots. We have put 62,000+ in home improvement in the last 2 years, Pella windows & all entry doors & sliding door, new boiler, new hot water tank, new roof, remodeled kitchen, new built in appliances, porcelain floor, 2 full baths taken down to the studs granite & silestone vanity tops porcelain tile floor and shower, all new interior doors, closet doors, all new light fixtures interior & exterior, new carpet, baseboard, interior paint through out.

With all that said he noted $15,000 in home improvements and a few windows replaced all but 5 windows have been replaced. He adjusted the replacement sq. ft @ $79. The acres he gave $5,750 for adjustment, 1 acres lot in Solon is selling for $78,000.
He appraised our property @ $291,000 which we needed $347,000. Why didn't he use comps that are apples to apples not apples to zucchini ? QuickenLoans will not order a second appraisal even through I was able to give them comps that just sold last month @ $380,000 which was built the same year close to the acreage and 4 bdrms & 3 full baths. We have lost our 4.375% rate lock and have no recourse. And our $500 lock rate deposit. What happened????? Can you shed any light on this and suggestions?

Thanks for your time.


Curious George being a monkey, I did a little look-see in the MLS and sent the following reply :

Thanks for the query.

I assume that you are referring to the home at --- Road, 44022. The Cuyahoga County Auditor shows that the home is a 2436 sf ranch, on about 2.65 acres, built about 1979 with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a half bath, full basement, and a 3-car garage. The tax appraised value for 2008 was $292,400, including the tax appraised land value of $68,400.

You need to realize that the lender will be looking at the same public records information, and underwriters are currently being very conservative.

I cannot address specifics in your question since I do not appraise in Cuyahoga County and cannot claim competence in that market area. There are, however, some very general items that you might want to look at.

You imply that only three comparables were used. I am finding that I have to use from 5-9 comps on the grid, including 1 or 2 active listings to show the market trend. Because of the scarcity of sales, the first three comps may be "ugly" due to the need to keep their sales dates within 6 months; it is not always easy to "bracket" under tough market conditions.

You also need to remember that cost is not the same as value. You may want to take a look at Remodeling Magazine's Cost vs Value Report .

I performed a search of the MLS looking for sales only in Orange. In 2006, there were 33 sales with a median price of $307,000, in 2007 there were 24 sales with a median price of $348,875, in 2008 there were 27 sales with a median price of $260,000, and for the first five months of 2009, there were only 5 sales with a median price of $165,600. While the MLS does not show all the sales that have taken place, it does show the brokered sales that most likely have occurred with adequate market exposure and can be used to form a value opinion which meets the FNMA definition of "market value". The statistics show the actual trend in prices for brokered sales in the Orange market.



I would suggest that you examine the appraisal report done in November 2007. You have implied that the value opinion was $396,000, or about $162/sf. There was a home which sold at 28700 Jackson Road on 4/26/2007 for $290,000 ($120/sf). That home was a 2413 sf ranch on 2.55 acres built in 1962. While it did not have a basement, in my opinion it would be a logical candidate as a comparable sale even though it might have to be heavily adjusted for that feature. In fact, examination of the MLS sales data shows that even in 2007, with a much higher median price than now, there were very few single-story homes in Orange that sold for more than $130/sf.

You may want to write a letter to the Ohio Division of Real Estate expressing your concerns, and forward to them copies of both appraisals for their review.

Sincerely,


Without a doubt this homeowner is feeling the pain of current market conditions on his financial situation. He may be under the impression that all is well in his neighborhood, but there are very few locales where real estate prices have not dipped. I have been tracking the MLS statistical reports for the entire state since 2003 (via the updates published in Ohio Realtor) and for the first 4 months of 2009, the median sales price across the entire NEOHREX MLS area is down more than 21% from the same period in 2008. I don't think we have hit bottom yet, either. My opinion.

Thursday, April 2, 2009

Oy! Such Enthusiasm!

On November 23rd I wrote,

"I have several very bitter disagreements with the tax thieves. One has to do with their desire to strangle the taxpayer. The term "mark to market" is now getting some attention, but it is an old IRS tactic that was adopted by the people who invent accounting rules. According to the IRS, if the market interest rate is 5%, and I loan you money at 1%, you must pay income tax on the 4% I did not charge you. The accountants were forced by this tactic to come up with a definition of "fair value" that relies on the current market price, even for assets which a taxpayer does not intend to sell. If I buy stock at $1/share on December 30, 2008, and it goes to $2/share on December 31, 2008, and back down to $1/share on January 2, 2009, I have a gain of $1/share for the 2008 tax year, even if it was not realized. For a cash basis taxpayer, there is no effect, but for an accrual basis taxpayer, there is an imaginary taxable gain of 100%. This is the result of "marking the value of the asset at current market price". The tax must be paid in 2009, and you can take a write-off for the imaginary January 2 loss in 2010. IRS will use your money, interest free, in the meantime.

When "mark to market" is applied to assets that are being held for income generating purposes, the decline in the market price of those assets can cause catastrophic effects in the credit ratings of companies. That is why so many lenders and insurance companies are now in a credit crisis. That is why throwing money at the problem will not help. The rules have to change. I advocate that "mark to market" be used only for assets actually traded, and "value in use" be given more emphasis where accrual accounting is utilized. IRS will not be happy with such a concept."


Note that I qualified the conditions for change; that "mark to market" be used only for assets actually traded.

Yesterday (April Fools' Day), bowing to pressure from the banks and the politicians, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB Issues Staff Position 141(R)-1) revised the rules regarding "mark to market". It is a lengthy read. The market has reacted quite positively today to the release of the statement. I have very strong doubts that many of the market participants have read anything beyond the news headlines about the statement.

Of interest to an appraiser is the following :

"8. If the acquisition-date fair value of an asset acquired or a liability assumed in a business combination that arises from a contingency cannot be determined during the measurement period, an asset or a liability shall be recognized at the acquisition date if both of the following criteria are met:

a. Information available before the end of the measurement period indicates that it is probable that an asset existed or that a liability had been incurred at the acquisition date.
It is implicit in this condition that it must be probable at the acquisition date that one or more future events confirming the existence of the asset or liability will occur.

b. The amount of the asset or liability can be reasonably estimated.

Criteria (a) and (b) shall be applied using the guidance in Statement 5 and in FASB Interpretation No. 14, Reasonable Estimation of the Amount of a Loss, for application of similar criteria in paragraph 8 of Statement 5."


Remember, an appraiser is one who provides an opinion of market value, while an accountant (or a computer program) provides an estimate of market value. Estimates can be prepared in the complete absence of consideration of the market participants, but opinions must consider what the market participants are actually reacting to.

The following disclaimer was also of interest [my bolds for emphasis]:

"This FSP was adopted by the affirmative votes of four members of the Financial Accounting Standards Board. Mr. Linsmeier dissented.

Mr. Linsmeier dissents from issuance of this FSP because it fails to provide guidance in two key areas, and, therefore, he does not believe the FSP will be operational. First, this FSP requires that an acquirer recognize at fair value an asset acquired or a liability assumed in a business combination that arises from a contingency if the acquisition-date fair value of that asset or liability can be determined during the measurement period without providing guidance as to how to make this assessment. This assessment drives the key differences in the accounting prescribed by this FSP and, if not clear, is likely to raise significant application and comparability issues. Statement 157 provides guidance on how to determine fair value in active and inactive markets and in the presence of both observable inputs and unobservable inputs, which might suggest that fair value should be able to be determined in many, if not most, circumstances. Mr. Linsmeier is concerned that without providing guidance on how to make this determination assessment the Board is being unclear about its intentions, introducing significant judgment in the application of this FSP that will not result in consistent reporting across enterprises.

Second, this FSP does not prescribe in detail how an asset or a liability arising from a contingency initially recognized at fair value in a business combination would be measured subsequent to its initial recognition. This FSP only requires that an acquirer develop a systematic and rational basis for subsequently measuring and accounting for such assets and liabilities depending on their nature, suggesting in the basis for conclusions to this FSP that methods be developed similar to those prescribed in Interpretation 45. While not stated in this FSP, the Board in its deliberations leading to this FSP generally agreed that Statement 5 does not provide appropriate guidance for the subsequent accounting for an asset or a liability arising from a contingency initially recognized at fair value in a business combination. In addition, the majority of the Board did not support subsequent accounting at fair value for those assets and liabilities. The failure to make these tentative decisions authoritative in this FSP and the failure to provide further guidance on the subsequent accounting similar to Interpretation 45 are likely to result in multiple methods for accounting and reporting for identical assets acquired and liabilities assumed in a business combination subsequent to their initial recognition at fair value, causing significant comparability issues for financial statement users across enterprises. As a consequence, Mr. Linsmeier believes this FSP fails to provide sufficient guidance to permit financial statement issuers and their auditors to consistently apply the guidance in this FSP and, as a result, financial statement users will not be provided useful and comparable information about the financial statement effects of assets acquired and liabilities assumed in a business combination that arise from contingencies. "


The Appendix to the statement includes the following items:

"B28. The Board acknowledges that this FSP does not provide investors, creditors, and other users of financial statements with some information that would have been provided had Statement 141(R) not been amended. However, because this FSP will continue to require that an acquirer disclose the amount of the asset or liability recognized at the acquisition date and the nature of the contingency, investors, creditors, and other users of financial statements will receive more information than they received under Statement 141. The Board believes the changes to Statement 141(R) made by this FSP were necessary to address operational issues raised by various constituents that could have resulted in significant costs to preparers.

B32. Differences also exist between the disclosures required by Statement 141(R), as amended by this FSP, and revised IFRS 3. For an asset or liability arising from a contingency recognized at the acquisition date, this FSP requires that the acquirer disclose the amount recognized and the nature of the contingency. For contingencies that are not recognized at the acquisition date, this FSP requires that the acquirer include the disclosures required by Statement 5 in the footnote that describes the business combination. For contingencies in which there is at least a reasonable possibility that a loss will be incurred, Statement 5 requires that an entity disclose the nature of the contingency and give an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss or state that such an estimate cannot be made. Revised IFRS 3 carries forward the existing disclosure requirements in IAS 37 and requires an acquirer to disclose the reasons that the fair value of a contingent liability cannot be measured reliably, if applicable. For recognized contingencies, the acquirer is required to disclose (a) a brief description of the nature of the obligation and the expected timing of any resulting outflows of economic benefits, (b) an indication of the uncertainties about the amount or timing of those outflows, including major assumptions made about future events, where necessary, to provide adequate information, and (c) the amount of any expected reimbursement and the amount of any asset that has been recognized for that expected reimbursement. For unrecognized contingencies, unless the possibility of any outflow in settlement is remote, the acquirer is required to disclose the nature of the contingency and, where practicable, (1) an estimate of its financial effect, (2) an indication of the uncertainties relating to the amount or timing of any outflow, and (3) the possibility of any reimbursement. Under IAS 37, entities also are required to disclose changes in the carrying amount of a contingent liability, including the reasons for those changes. "


The market rally today was said to be a result of investors hoping to see financial stocks show improved profit conditions as a result of application of this rule. While this rule will help in situations where assets held for income production are being analyzed, I would have to agree with Mr. Linsmeier that there is insufficient guidance with respect to supplying investors with information where assets which have defaulted or are in danger of default are being valued. In particular, the downward price pressure on the housing market has, I believe, been understated because the statistics being analyzed have not been adequately filtered to reflect market value as perceived by buyers.

Once the idea sinks in that this is not a cure for the mortgage portfolio devaluation problem, we may see some "morning after" regrets. Choking on furballs is always a danger when one partakes of the hair of the dog which bit him.

Sunday, November 23, 2008

Commercial Break

This past week I was prompted by Mickey Axlebender Thirdson to pontificate on deflation, since people were talking about it but did not seem to know what it meant. Of course, if one is speaking of pneumatic tires, deflation causes a "flat", and if one is talking about a bore (as in, politician who won't shut up) the term has no meaning since the bore is a boor and cannot be embarrassed sufficiently to become deflated. However, when one is speaking about economics, then the common sentiment is that deflation is when prices go down.

It is a bit more complicated than that, though. Perhaps we need to look first at "inflation", which everyone thinks they understand. We will need a place to stand on if we are going to move the Earth, saith Archimedes, and that place in economics will be a standard medium of exchange. Gold comes to mind quickly, as does the cost of a loaf of bread. The USBuck has been taken to be the standard for the past half century (yes, Virginia, there was a time when other currencies were considered the standard -- see "pieces of eight", for example) and the rise of the Euro notwithstanding, foreign investors have rallied back to the dollar recently because, relative to what is happening in the rest of the world, and in spite of US economic woes, the USBuck is still the most confidence-inspiring piece of paper afloat.

Inflation is generally seen to be a process whereby prices are rising. There is a need to understand why prices rise. In a rational economic world, prices rise due to a rise in demand relative to a decline in supply. In other words, people are bidding for something, and the competition drives up the price. There are multiple intertwining factors in action, however. One factor is the item being purchased, and another is the perceived value of the currency used. In other words, the USBuck is a commodity in trade. In general, the more USBucks there are in circulation, the less valuable they become, and the more of them are required to barter for the item being purchased. When the government creates more USBucks, to the buyer, the USBuck has become less valuable, and to the seller, the item being sold has become more valuable. Inflation in the price of the commodity being sold, where the demand for the commodity has not increased, is actually caused by deflation of the value of the currency used in trade.

So, we flashback to Jimmy Stewart in "It's A Wonderful Life", and we see him instructing Momma Dollar and Poppa Dollar to hide in the safe and create lots of little dollars. Unwittingly, Frank Capra was commenting on the reason why FDR was unable to solve the problem of the Great Depression with all of his programs. They all tended to create little dollars.

Entrepreneurial buzz is full of the concept of "creating wealth". Wealth is "created" when a product, for which there is a demand, is produced. Too much of the "wealth creation" that has taken place has simply been fabricated through artificial accounting constructs. One popular method has been to provide seller financing of a piece of real estate. The seller needs money and is looking for a buyer, and the buyer has no money and wants the property, so the seller "creates" the money by allowing the buyer to make payments over the life of the contract. There is risk involved, and the seller compensates for the risk and charges interest (the time value of the money) to make up for the fact that he cannot use all of the sales price right away (opportunity cost has to be compensated for). The money used to make the payments (USBucks printed by the Federal Reserve) was originally intended to be used in direct exchange for goods and services without any adjustment for lost opportunity costs. Because the terms of the contract are now competing directly with the interests of the private banking system (the Federal Reserve), feedback in the economy forces the Federal Reserve to print additional USBucks to protect its own position. Money has been "created". This does not necessarily lead to a decline in the value of the USBuck IF there has been a corresponding increase in the total goods and services being traded and in the number of buyers of those things. Unfortunately, as has been pointed out in prior posts, there is a huge oversupply of housing (the most common wealth creation venue under the above scenario) and the net effect of the increase in USBucks has been to lower their value in trade.

Deflation is commonly taken to be the situation when prices are falling. Why do prices fall? Prices fall either because there is too much "stuff" for sale -- no demand for the "stuff" -- or because the number of USBucks available has declined. If there are fewer USBucks, then the demand for USBucks rises, and the buyer is entitled to get more "stuff" for fewer USBucks because of the relative value. To look at the backside of it, deflation caused by a reduction of the number of USBucks in circulation is actually inflation in the buying power of the USBuck. My opinion -- William Jennings Bryan, with his "Cross of Gold" speech, was a blithering populist idiot who did not seem to realize that the alternative to crucifying the farmer with the gold standard was to suffocate the rest of the country with worthless paper.

Sad to say, it appears that just now the deflation in the worth of the dollar is coinciding with a deflation in the worth of the goods and services in some sectors of the economy. There are too many houses; about 10% of the total housing stock should be bulldozed and returned to cropland or some other productive use. There are too many cars (particularly cheaply made, breakdown-prone, high-priced, gas-guzzling ones) -- a fact easily illustrated by the lack of car sales having very little impact on whether or not Americans are still getting to wherever they want to go. There are too many mortgages that were made at below-market teaser rates and which will default as the rates reset to market and the borrowers can no longer afford to pay.

The government response has been fantastically stupid. Instead of listening to economists, the Congress and Senate chose to listen to every plaintiff whose ox had been gored, especially the Federal Reserve bankers. In the blink of an eye, the Federal Reserve was allowed to create $700,000,000,000 of new BailoutBucks, a move which cheapened the money in everyone's pocket overnight. Prices should have shot upwards, but one other factor was at work -- the machinations of the Infernal Revenue Service.

I have several very bitter disagreements with the tax thieves. One has to do with their desire to strangle the taxpayer. The term "mark to market" is now getting some attention, but it is an old IRS tactic that was adopted by the people who invent accounting rules. According to the IRS, if the market interest rate is 5%, and I loan you money at 1%, you must pay income tax on the 4% I did not charge you. The accountants were forced by this tactic to come up with a definition of "fair value" that relies on the current market price, even for assets which a taxpayer does not intend to sell. If I buy stock at $1/share on December 30, 2008, and it goes to $2/share on December 31, 2008, and back down to $1/share on January 2, 2009, I have a gain of $1/share for the 2008 tax year, even if it was not realized. For a cash basis taxpayer, there is no effect, but for an accrual basis taxpayer, there is an imaginary taxable gain of 100%. This is the result of "marking the value of the asset at current market price". The tax must be paid in 2009, and you can take a write-off for the imaginary January 2 loss in 2010. IRS will use your money, interest free, in the meantime.

When "mark to market" is applied to assets that are being held for income generating purposes, the decline in the market price of those assets can cause catastrophic effects in the credit ratings of companies. That is why so many lenders and insurance companies are now in a credit crisis. That is why throwing money at the problem will not help. The rules have to change. I advocate that "mark to market" be used only for assets actually traded, and "value in use" be given more emphasis where accrual accounting is utilized. IRS will not be happy with such a concept. It is not an accident that a recent Federal tax court decision (10/30/2008) ended in a ruling that disallowed a value for the cost of a historic facade restoration in New Orleans. IRS argued that only sales comparison should be used, and that cost and lost income should not be considered. "Judge James S. Halpern ruled that the court would not supplant its responsibility to assess an expert appraiser's reliability by accepting USPAP as the defining standard of reliability, stating that federal rules of evidence only require that expert testimony be based on reliable principles and methods." (Appraiser News Online, November 19, 2008, Vol. 9, No. 21/22). In short, the IRS can ignore Congress and make things up as it goes along.

Deflation? The horse is out of the barn, but it's a mule. There are too many USBucks running around out there. The politicians are planning to print more in an attempt to "stimulate" the economy. There is too much "stuff" for sale, and the only way out of the rabbit hole is to either reduce the amount of "stuff", or reduce the number of USBucks. Meanwhile, back at the ranch, prices will continue to go down, and the country will suffocate in excess USBucks.

Too simplistic? If I have to cut my throat, I would rather do it with Occam's Razor.

Friday, November 21, 2008

A Rent Survey

Well, I guess I'd better get started on this.

First, we need to do a rent survey, to see what investors are asking in the Akron area. Checking the Akron Beacon Journal for November 20, 2008, we find 241 rental ads running and 43 single-family homes for rent that we can identify by address. Using the Auditor's website, we fill in the missing data -- sometimes the bath count, always the GLA, separating out attic finish (which may contain a room used as a bedroom, but which many investors seal off as a liability concern), and checking for a garage.

The rent survey follows:
It appears that on average, there is a $37/bedroom difference between a 4-bedroom rental and a 3-bedroom rental, and about a $92/bedroom difference between a 3-bedroom rental and a 2-bedroom rental. It also appears that the 2-bedroom rentals, being smaller and possibly easier to maintain, return a higher rent/square foot ($0.63) than the others.

Our investor may possibly want to concentrate on 2-bedroom homes, which will likely fit his purchase budget more easily as well.

Thursday, May 8, 2008

Second Base


Realizing that improved real estate is a depreciable asset (have you ever filled out Form 1040, Schedule E?), an honest investor who truly wishes to get a return on an investment in rental real estate should first get a handle on the meaning of capitalization. In case you were wondering, that has a good deal to do with the term capitalism, which is a dirty word to some people who think that failing to properly capitalize a venture is a virtue.

Capitalization refers to the ability to reasonably compare the costs of an asset to the benefits that derive from owning it. Accountants are familiar with the concept, but most amateur real estate investors, sad to say, are not. Even Jesus warned about the dangers of failing to capitalize ventures. I won't tell you where He said that; you have to look it up for yourself, but it is there and He was very clear about it.

An investor who has no start-up capital is on shaky ground. I know, having started several businesses on shoestrings and losing my shirt because I was undercapitalized. Therefore, we will give our hypothetical investor the tidy sum of $10,000, and see what he could (maybe should) do with it.

There is a basic formula for calculating the income produced by an investment : Income = Rate * Value. If we consider putting the $10,000 in the bank at 0.2% interest (which is about what some banks are paying right now on savings accounts and CDs), then the annual income (simple interest) on $10,000 would be R * V = 0.002 * 10,000 = $20. That is not much of an incentive for saving. It is one of the reasons why intervention by the Federal Reserve, lowering interest rates to stimulate the economy, will ultimately have disastrous effects. The only people who will win that one are the bankers, who get to use every one else's capital virtually for free.

Our investor could put the money into the stock market. There are many solid mutual funds that have been paying 8%-12% per year. What is important to look at, though, is the mix of the annual return from those funds. How much is due to dividends paid by the companies that the fund invested in, and how much is due to capital gains that the fund earned through stock speculation? If the latter has been a very high percentage of the annual gain, the new market economics may soon make that fund much less appealing than one which derives a higher percentage of its gains through dividends paid on annual production.

In the end, all solid gains come from the production of goods and services. Rental real estate is a service which produces places in which people can live. The rates of gain from those things are regularly published. For real estate investors, the Appraisal Institute publishes the Korpacz Real Estate Investor Survey© National Market Indicators, which is a gold mine of data on current capitalization rates for various types of real estate.

An example would be the Overall Cap Rate for Apartments for the 4th quarter of 2007 (3.5%-8%, with a mean rate of 5.75%), or the Residual Cap Rate for Apartments for the 4th quarter of 2007 (4.5%-8.5%, with a mean rate of 6.58%). These are rates obtained by surveys of market participants; they are the rates that are being reported by serious investors in this field. They are also bellweathers for the economy in general, since any inflation rate (driven by artificially low interest rates) that exceeds the mean cap rates for a class of investment makes it economically foolish to hold that investment class.

Our investor also must study the care and feeding of his investment. We will assume he wants to buy a house and rent it out to generate income. He would like to have the largest gains possible, but he is a young sprout of 35 years, and would like to make an investment that he can still be drawing income from 30 years from now, when he retires. For this reason he prudently seeks a rate of return that appears supported by professional investors in his investment class.

Our investor will buy a house. Out of the gross rent, he will pay a mortgage, taxes, insurance, and anything that is needed in the way of maintenance. When he is ready to pass on, he will have not only earned an income over a lifetime, but will also have built an equity position. That equity position, however, should be considered a windfall bonus if it turns out to be a gain that beats the inflation rate, because in order to maintain the property, he will have to make further capital improvements over the life of the investment lest it depreciate through negligence to the point where it would be worth less than the original purchase price and also possibly lose its income generation potential.

Our investor will start with $10,000, and hope to match the Overall Cap Rate for Apartments (about 6%, or $600 in annual net gain). For the sake of simplicity, we will stick with the short term implications, fully realizing that as his equity position increases, the theoretical yield should also rise. The fact that the monthly payments on the loan will remain constant (we will assume he goes the full 30 years without refinancing) make a short-term analysis more realistic.

Next time we will help our investor choose his investment property.

Wednesday, April 2, 2008

Finding the First Corner


Fable of the Day


An old man watched a young boy tease a bear that was tied to a tree with a rope. Each time the bear would rise, the boy would back off. Each time the bear would sink back down, the boy would poke it with a long stick. The old man asked, "Sonny, what do you think you are doing? If that bear gets loose, it will tear you and everybody else in the neighborhood to shreds."

"No worry, old man." says the boy. "I'm just playing the stock market."


.........................................


We proceed with my underlying claim that an investment whose value is based solely on the ability to "flip" an asset is on shaky ground.

The Fannie Mae Form 216 (Aug '88), Operating Income Statement, is a frequently neglected tool that should be included with any appraisal of a 1-4 family income residence and critically scrutinized. The biggest problems (at least from my perspective) center around the facts that:
  • most appraisers have no real-world experience or training in the maintenance and operation of a residential rental
  • most appraisers lack the experience to adequately address the need for periodic repairs to real property, and,
  • as a result, appraisers using the 216 generally accept borrower estimates or simply PFA to fill in the blanks.
When this is followed by a reviewer or an underwriter who may not have been adequately trained to spot inconsistencies between the appraisal report and the 216, the Monthly Operating Income developed on the 216 will provide an unrealistic or even fraudulent indication of the property's net income generation potential. Fannie Mae requires this form to be properly filled out and submitted with every Fannie Mae 1025, Small Residential Income Property Appraisal.

The 216 should also be completed for every single-family appraisal (Fannie Mae Form 1004) where the home is to be used as a rental. It usually is not, however, because loan officers do not want to pay the additional fee most appraisers charge to do extra work, and in any event, it is easy to get around by simply claiming that the home is to be owner occupied. Unfortunately, there is no space on the forms to indicate whether the borrower already owns a dozen single-family homes within the county. (Such information is embarrassingly easy to find and is sometimes very difficult to hide, but has nothing to do with the valuation of the subject property. The amount of fraud seen by the average appraiser is incredible, but reporting it can be hazardous to his business. Maybe I should post a few war stories?)

If the subject property is a single-family residence that will be used as a rental, the Fannie Mae 1007 (8/88), Single Family Comparable Rent Schedule should also be filled out. This will provide an estimate of the subject's gross income potential, as of the appraisal date. In general, the rent comparables used in the Fannie Mae 1025 will be used for the same purpose if the property is a 2-4 family rental.

The front of the 216 is used to project the anticipated income and expenses for the next 12 months. It is sometimes necessary to survey income property owners to get a feel for what is typical in a given neighborhood; quite often the subject property's owner will underestimate his actual expenses. The form carries this statement :

"If the appraiser is retained to complete the form instead of the applicant, the lender must provide to the appraiser the aforementioned operating statements (n.b ' actual year-end operating statements for the past two years'), mortgage insurance premium, HOA dues, leasehold payments, subordinate financing, and/or any other relevant information as to the income and expenses of the subject property received from the applicant to substantiate the projections."

In over 20 years of residential appraisal practice, I have never had a lender provide that information. I always had to acquire it from the applicant, the property owner (if it was a sale), or market surveys. Many borrowers treat a request for such information with an attitude of offense, and market surveys are time-consuming because the competition in the rental market makes landlords treat such information as proprietary. It is, nevertheless, critical data, and on more than one occasion I have had to conclude that the projected Net Operating Income shows that the landlord's business is not viable. Once that happens, you have a very unhappy investor, who will never again willingly give you data about his investment plan. You also will have a very unhappy loan officer, who will try to guarantee that you never again get an appraisal order from his company.

So, what is so difficult about this Form 216? For one thing, is asks for items like projected vacancy and the "customary expenses that a professional management company would charge to manage the property". Those two items alone can sink the NOI. The second page, though, is the real killer. On page 2 is the Replacement Reserve Schedule. Many investors will ask, "What is THAT?". THAT is what causes many of the investors in my market to lose their investment.

Even assuming that the rental is unfurnished, and the tenant must supply stove and refrigerator, items like dishwashers, furnaces, central air units, and water heaters need periodic replacement. It is not unusual to see an appraiser indicate on a form that a home has a Remaining Economic Life of 40-50 years (hey - would you make a 30 year loan if the REL was 30 years or less?). Let us suppose you are talking about a duplex, with two of each. Assuming the equipment is brand spanking new the day of the appraisal, in a 50 year period the investor will need to buy and install two furnaces, four central air units, eight water heaters, and eight dishwashers. That is based on average life expectancies for those items. He will also need to re-roof the building at least once, and, based on my experience and the experiences related to me by local investors, will need to totally replace the flooring -- carpet and vinyl -- about nine times. Assuming he sells it at the end of the fifty year period, on that schedule, all of the replacement items would be needing to be replaced at that point, and he would be selling a building in need of updating.

The Replacement Reserve Schedule provides an amount that should be set aside each month to have money in reserve to complete the repairs that will be required over time. A wise lender would require an escrow account for those items, but using that criterion, I have never done business with a wise lender. Those figures are totaled and transferred to page 1 and added to all the other expenses to give the Total Operating Expenses. The numbers are then reconciled: the Total Operating Expenses are subtracted from the Effective Gross Income and divided by 12 to give a Monthly Operating Income. The Monthly Operating Income is then reduced by the Monthly Housing Expense (P & I on the mortgage, hazard insurance, property taxes, MIP, etc) to give a Net Cash Flow. If this form were completed honestly and properly, the percentage of loans made on residential rental real estate would plummet. In most cases, the only way to generate a positive cash flow is to reduce the amount that is to be borrowed, since that is usually the largest single monthly expense. This calls for a bigger down payment, and would spell the end of cash-out refinancing of most rental properties.

Next time we will look into the case of the honest investor who wants to actually get an income from real estate rental property, and expects to hold the property for a lengthy period of time.

Tuesday, April 1, 2008

Cornering a Market

As a review appraiser, one of the biggest problems with appraisals of residential investment properties -- rental homes -- has been the lack of careful attention by the appraiser to the actual return on investment anticipated by the investor. If the investor were putting money into a stock, he would surely be interested in whether that stock was likely to earn money and pay dividends. The investor would look at the money in hand, examine the alternate choices (i.e., bank interest, other stocks, bonds, state lottery, etc) and see what rate of return could be expected. That caution has been lacking in recent decades, as investors look at stocks from the standpoint of their possible resale value (buy low, sell high) rather than their income generation potential (long term gain through dividends).

When it is realized that the entire rationale for the existence of the stock market is the generation of capital for start-up and expansion of a business enterprise, the prostitution of the market by those who use the change in stock price as their sole reason for participation should give shareholders and directors reason to very seriously consider the potential negative consequences of going public with the stock, for, at that point, the financial stability of the company becomes hostage to the perceived profit-taking ability by the market at large.

The real estate industry has been taken over by this same mind-set. It was the anticipation of a quick profit by the property "flippers" that drove the real estate bubble, much the same way that stock "flippers" have driven other "bubbles" in financial markets. The "flippers" made their money by buying low and selling high. Just as the stock market attracted non-traditional investors, the real estate market attracted "flippers" across the spectrum. It was not unusual during the bubble years for Average Joe to buy a house, live in it for a year or so, then sell and buy another, making a small (sometimes large) profit and moving up in the world. Indeed, there is nothing wrong with that kind of approach to real estate. The problem arises when Other Peoples' Money (OPM) enters the equation.

If you have a few spare shekels of your own, what you do with them is your own business. You can engage in risky economic behavior because it is YOUR money. If you went to the local bank and said, "I would like a personal loan so I can buy some lottery tickets, and I will offer the tickets as collateral", any rational banker would either throw you out or die from laughter. (That is not to say that if you looked hard enough, you could find an irrational banker.)

The basic underpinning of the study of economics is an understanding of the relationship between supply and demand. That relationship is never perfect; it is always in flux. Today I demand eggs for breakfast, tomorrow I demand cereal. What I pay for breakfast today is determined by how many eggs there are to be had, and how many other people want eggs. If eggs are scarce, and many people want them today, I may have to pay the California Gold Rush price of $100 per egg today, and if everybody wants cereal tomorrow, the guy who wants to sell a dozen eggs tomorrow may not get $1 for the whole dozen. Supply and demand; the market works in cycles and despite the claims of experts, is unpredictable because it involves the perceived wants and needs of people, and every day brings a new itch to be scratched.

Therefore, if I go to the bank to borrow money for an investment, the banker wants to know what the value of that investment will be over the life of the loan. He wants to know if it will be a winner or a loser. If I want to invest in Pet Rocks, he wants to know if they produce dividend income, or if they have good resale potential. For that reason, few sane bankers will loan money for an investment in a day at the horse races, or even an investment in the stock market. Such gambles are heavily regulated.

When the public fell for the canard that residential real estate was a good investment, most people failed to recognize that what they were falling for was a property flipping scheme, and not a dividend stream investment. The mantra was that real estate never goes down in value, therefore it was "safe". It was thus felt that using OPM was legitimate for property "flipping", whether done by investors who had that as their sole objective, or by Average Joe, who just wanted to make a profit when he sold his house.

Enter government social engineering. Very few economists are elected to Congress. This is also a result of the Law of Supply and Demand, but I will leave the reader to figure out what I mean by that. Official government policy for several decades has tried to maximize home ownership, without regard to whether the new homeowners understood their responsibilities. This has resulted in lowering the equity barrier for entry into the real estate market, and the lowered requirements have been extended even to non-owner-occupied dwellings.

In previous years, it was believed that a loan to value ratio of 80% was a reasonable risk, and borrowers with less than 20% down were required to purchase mortgage insurance, either through a GSE (FHA insurance) or through private mortgage insurance (PMI) companies. The insurance was then used to guarantee the repayment to the lender in the event of default.

Because of the common belief that values were increasing (based partly on government indexes that measure the buying power of the dollar) the property "flipping" could continue as long as a higher resale price could be obtained by the investor. Little real attention was paid to the actual return earned on the investment. This was where the Operating Income Statement -- the Form 216 -- should have been of greater concern. It is also where the use of Gross Rent Multipliers (GRMs) lead to false impressions of value.

Enough for now, I have other things that must be done at the moment. The investment idea that I am toying with will be developed over the next few posts.

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Sad Stories Abound

I read today a story about a woman in Southern California who, in February, lost her $70,000 per year job, and less than two months later, is obtaining food for herself and her two children from a food bank because she did not qualify for Food Stamps. She was uncertain of her future, with a $2500/month interest only loan on her home. Comments to the news story were mostly sympathetic, but there were a number of people who could not see how someone making $70,000 a year could go broke so quickly. It seems that a huge number of Americans never make anywhere near that kind of money and have learned to live on less than half that amount.

So here's my sad story. Yesterday I went out on an appraisal assignment for a refinance. The house was an older dwelling, straddling two parcels. The front parcel was zoned commercial, and the rear parcel residential. The property does not conform to zoning. The home had a new roof, and the windows had been replaced a while ago with insulated glass units, and the basement had just been waterproofed. It still had a septic sewage system, even though the city sewer line was stubbed out to the property at the street.

The gentleman wanted to talk, and I let him. He showed me the front property pin, which was under his driveway; part of the drive was on the neighbor's property. He showed me the septic tank lids, which were right on the property line. Worse yet, the septic tank had a spruce tree growing on top of it, and there was no way of telling which way the effluent drained, if it drained at all. He showed me the basement, with its new, professionally done waterproofing, and also the missing basement steps (we had to climb down a step ladder) that the contractor had removed and not replaced, and the partially removed partition wall that he said the contractor had not completely removed because he was afraid the floor above would sag. He showed me the crumbling and collapsing plaster on an upstairs ceiling, where water had been leaking in for some time before he had the roof reshingled.

Not quite a slam-dunk as a valuation problem.

He told me his story. He once had a good paying job, years ago, but the company closed up shop in the northern part of the state. It seems that the union was based in Cleveland, and insisted on Cuyahoga County wages for workers in Summit County, where things just were not as expensive as they were further north. For years he had worked at odd jobs, and was now drawing his Social Security. His wife was bringing in most of the current income, working as a waitress, and she seemed very displeased with life. She shut herself in the bathroom, and it was with great difficulty that he was able to persuade her to come out and allow me to examine that room. With poverty there is often familial distress.

It seems that easy money was part of the problem. He had refinanced the house in 2004, and if it was an 80% refinance, then the appraisal at that time was probably close to the actual market value. But, in 2005, he needed to fix the roof, and he took out a home equity loan. That brought him close to 100% financing. He was also paying a very high interest rate for his car, and last August, refinanced his home equity loan to roll the balance that he owed on the car into the second mortgage. Bad move. The HELOC is adjustable, and he is upside-down on his mortgage. He was trying to refinance to roll it all into one lower interest fixed rate loan, but based on the fact that prices in his neighborhood have been falling at about 1%/month since 2006, and the needed repairs, I think he is stuck right where he is.

He told me where he needed to have the value come in (and I doubt that he realized he was engaging in a criminal act by doing so); it would have been far better from the standpoint of making the loan if the appraiser who had appraised it last August had been there yesterday instead of me. Had that appraiser accurately reported in August the problems with the site alone, I doubt the loan would have been made. Then again, it was a different bank, and we are in a different economic world than we were in just a few months ago. I have a feeling that my opinion of value is going to contribute to greater marital discord.

I wish I could help, but I think the solution is to be found only by squeezing through the tunnel. How did we, as a nation, get in such a fix? It may be simple human insecurity. We are herd animals, afraid of judgment and always seeking peer approval. People live beyond their means because they need to put up a public front. Just like the people who will speed up on the highway because somebody is tailgating them, rather than sticking to their convictions about obeying the law, we somehow rationalize that it is OK to engage in risky economic activity because "everyone else is doing it". We think that safety lies in numbers, and delude ourselves about the virtues of democracy. It is not a virtue to collectively go broke.

Wednesday, March 19, 2008

Let's Hope She Still Has Her Voice

I am glad I am not Ben Bernanke. Or George W. Bush. Or the head of the OTC, Fannie, Freddie, or Ginnie, or the Secretary of the Treasury. Or a CEO of any of the major lenders.

One reason is that I do not at all understand the machinations occurring in the financial markets right now. I do understand a few basic themes :

  • when supply is low and demand is high, prices go up

  • when supply is high and demand is low, prices go down

  • when people cannot afford to pay their debts, they default

  • when risk is high, investors look for high yields

  • when a man is broke and his credit is bad, he goes without

I also see the following things in the marketplace :

  • incomes have not kept pace with expenses for the majority of Americans

  • residential real estate lending provided much of the means for consumption in the past decade

  • there are far more houses in the market than there are buyers who can afford them

  • the loans that were made in 2005-2006 are at their peak for their first reset


For a decade I have been warning that the use of Home Equity Lines of Credit are not only dangerous, but have the effect of robbing the Average Joe's piggy bank. Most Joes have no idea that when they borrow against their home, they sell an interest to the lender. They do not stop to consider that when Sharkey loans them the money, he expects to make a profit. Therefore, the interest he takes in the home is ALWAYS greater than the amount of money lent. In good times, this fact is difficult to visualize. Joe rarely thinks about his home as a savings account; he is often told that it is an investment. Nothing could be farther from the truth.

An investment is a vehicle for providing a return on capital. An investment that does not keep pace with inflation is a bad deal. A home is a place to live. No matter where Joe wants to live, he must pay rent. If the price of houses goes up, the landlord will raise the rent. If Joe buys the house, and sells an interest to Sharkey at a fixed rate, he has purchased a form of rent control. Then, if the price of houses goes up, Joe's monthly rent stays the same, and the equity he builds in the house becomes a hedge against future rent inflation. The hedge is usually not very high, because while land does not suffer from obsolescence, the improvements (der hut?) will depreciate (translation : deteriorate) and will need repairs from time to time. Joe will normally pay for those repairs out of his pocket.

Over time -- the life of the improvement or the life of the owner, whichever comes to an end first -- it is almost certain that the cost of maintaining and repairing the improvement will, with any inflation, equal the total equity Joe has in his home. New roofing, siding, windows, furnaces, water heaters, paint, carpeting, cabinets, etc. will have to be purchased and installed at least once (and maybe more -- figure three times for a water heater) during the typical 30 year amortization period. Joe will also need to address the cost of taxes and insurance. If Joe does not need to touch his equity in that time period, he will indeed have a lump-sum amount available if he would sell his home. But --

What if Joe borrows against that equity? For one thing, it is almost certain that the interest rate charged for a second mortgage or a line of credit will be higher than the rate on the first mortgage. If it is not, then Joe has been sleeping at the wheel and should have already refinanced his principal balance at a lower fixed rate. By borrowing against his equity, Joe has just raised his own rent. If he uses the money to repair his home, he might have made a wise move, especially if the cost could not be paid out of pocket and the repair was essential for maintaining the structure or systems and preventing further deterioration. Use of the equity for any other purpose is foolish unless Joe is fully willing to surrender to Sharkey (who is really his landlord, you see) control over the monthly rent.

What if Joe does not borrow against the equity, but sells the house he now owns free and clear and buys another? If he pays the same amount for his new home that he got for his old home, he will have actually gotten a raw deal unless his intent was only to move to a new location. If he moved up in the world and bought a more expensive home, he will borrow again; the cost of fancy digs is higher rent. A home is not an investment; at best it is a forced savings account and rent control device.

Alas, Joe has been suckered by Sharkey into a cash-out refinancing or a HELOC. Worse yet, Sharkey has convinced Joe that since house prices are rising, the value of Joe's house must be increasing, and therefore Joe can borrow MORE than the difference between what he originally paid and what he still owes. And, even worse, Sharkey has talked Joe into an adjustable rate loan -- a loan which Joe is qualified to take on at its lowest increment, but which he has no hope of keeping up the payments on after it resets a time or two.

By now we see that Average Joe has no idea what he is doing. (But if you ask him, he will tell you how good a deal he got from Sharkey. At least until the first reset of his loan.) Joe sells Sharkey the rest of his interest in his house, and spends the money on a new pickup and a bassboat and a cute car for the wife; they also go to Disney World and watch the Pirates of the Caribbean without catching the joke underneath. And, guess what? His neighbors, Harry and Sam and Bebop (have to be multi-cultural in this neighborhood, you know) do exactly the same thing. Twenty-four months later they each get a letter from Sharkey. Sharkey is raising their rent by 2% of the total amount they each owe.

Joe and Harry and Sam and Bebop each get together with their wives to discuss this new development. Harry's wife, Zelda Sue, tells him he was stupid, walks out, gets a divorce, and the house has to be sold for the settlement. Joe's wife and Bebop's wife agree with them that they had better sell their houses; the signs go up the next day. Sam has a heart attack over the whole matter and his widow is forced to sell to settle the estate. Suddenly, there are four houses for sale on Joe's block.

Think : when supply is high and demand is low, prices go down. Three months later, all four houses are still on the market, and the four neighbors (OK, so they do miss old Sam) are now busy trying to undercut each other with the prices. Sam's widow gets desperate, and sells the house for the loan balance just to get out from under it.

Think : when people cannot afford to pay their debts, they default. Harry gets fed up with the situation and disappears; he does send Joe a postcard from Ecuador where he has a new job with a pharmaceutical company.

Think : when risk is high, investors look for high yields. Bebop finally gets a buyer, but has to do a short sale. His credit is no good, but he does manage to get another house in a poorer section of town, buying it on Land Contract at 15% interest (but look at the bright side -- it's a fixed rate!).

Think : when a man is broke and his credit is bad, he goes without. Joe? Joe is evicted by the foreclosure order. He and his wife are living in the pickup, and they aren't planning any vacations for a while.

Wait a minute, you say. You forgot the first one : when supply is low and demand is high, prices go up. No, I didn't forget the first one. Sharkey convinced Joe that prices were going up. Sharkey had an appraiser who would hit his numbers. Sharkey quoted government figures that painted a rosy economic picture. Sharkey lied; he didn't tell Joe that the neighborhood was overbuilt and that there were lots of empty houses to go around.

So here is a snapshot of the economy. For a decade it was buoyed by consumer spending while American industrial production fell and imports rose. For a decade the Sharkeys convinced people that they could borrow their way to prosperity. For a decade the economy was based on mortgage fraud and government economic deceit. For a decade, the money supply was artificially inflated by low interest rates, and foreign investors were suckered into buying overvalued mortgage backed securities.

All good things (and all bad things) come to an end. When the money supply could no longer be stretched because the foreign balance of payments was causing imported goods to rise in cost, interest rates were raised. At the same time, the adjustable rate mortgages began to reset, and the borrowers could no longer afford their rent. As they began to default in large numbers, sales prices on existing homes began to drop in a competitive spiral. As the money supply tightened, new constructions became harder to sell, their prices also declined, and defaults among the buyers of more recent new homes rose, again dragging prices downward.

When it became apparent that the margin of profit on the adjustable rate mortgages was declining, the investors began to look for more profitable venues, and as they sold their securities, first the sub-prime lenders, and then the mainstream lenders began to suffer from a lack of cash to continue lending, even to good credit risks.

We are now in the second full year of this debacle. The peak number of first-time resets is now occurring. That means that the peak number of foreclosures from default will begin in about six months. Through this entire time period, some real estate sales have been occurring. As I examine the lending data, it is appalling to see the high percentage of 100% finances; a huge number of homes in the past two years, in the face of the subprime melt-down, have been financed with 80% conventional fixed first mortgages and 20% adjustable second mortgages to make the down payment. I can easily see strong foreclosure activity occurring as far along as three years from now, short of draconian measures on the order of nationalization of the lending industry and restructuring of the loans.

America has been cash poor for some time now. Foreign investors, lured by the seeming stability of the mortgage backed securities, provided a significant portion of the cash that fueled residential real estate finance and consumer spending, all the while piling up an imbalance in foreign debt. The recent forced buyout of Bear Stearns at the command of the Federal Reserve did little but lower foreign confidence in the securities. There are other brokerages just as upside down in their portfolios; an investor needs to ask whether the risk of losing equity in a fire sale such as the Bear sale is worth taking on.

Remember that it was the oversupply of money created by the Fed's low interest rate policy that drove the consumer spending and foreign payment imbalance. The willingness of the Fed to lend money to the troubled lenders by allowing them to borrow against shaky securities cannot make our foreign trading partners see the dollar as a currency worth holding. The lowering of the discount rate will make taking on additional debt backed by US assets even less palatable. It could even be that lowing the discount rate could make mortgage lending more difficult since there would be fewer foreign investors willing to risk such a low-paying venture. And what will Big Ben do if lowering the discount rate does not cure the problem? Lower it to 0%? Offer to PAY investors to take Fed money?

We are living in interesting times. As I said above I do not understand what is happening in the financial markets. I only know one little saying that might fit the situation.

"it ain't over until the Fat Lady sings."